Get three free stories set in the world of The Promise Trilogy Don't miss out!

The Flower Shop on State Street

The Flower Shop on State Street

The roses were for another man’s funeral.

On the morning of November 10, 1924, Dean O’Banion was working in his flower shop on North State Street, making up arrangements for the funeral of Mike Merlo — a Sicilian power broker who had died, remarkably for that time and that crowd, of natural causes. O’Banion knew funeral flowers. His shop, Schofield’s, sat directly across the street from the twin spires of Holy Name Cathedral, and it did a brisk, entirely legitimate trade in the wreaths and sprays that Chicago’s dead required in quantity. He was good at it. He liked it. And he was standing among his own buckets of chrysanthemums, shears in hand, when three men walked in.

One of them came forward with his hand out, the way you would to greet a friend. O’Banion, who had greeted a great many men that way, took it. The handshake held him in place while the other two drew their guns.

By the time the shears hit the floor, the most dangerous man on the North Side was dead among his flowers — and the shop that had made a fortune burying other people was about to bury him.

The two halves of Dean O’Banion

Dean O'Banion in a suit and tie on his wedding day in 1921, three years before his murder in his Chicago flower shop.

Dean O’Banion on his wedding day, February 5, 1921. Photographer unknown. Public domain.

There were, in a sense, always two Dean O’Banions. The first had sung in the choir at Holy Name as a boy — an altar boy with a sweet tenor and a limp from a childhood streetcar accident, kneeling at the very altar of the cathedral he would one day run a flower shop across from. The second grew up on the hard edge of the North Side and became, by his thirties, a safecracker, a hijacker of liquor trucks, and the head of the loose, ferocious coalition of men who ran the rackets on the North Side in the first raw years of Prohibition.

The flower shop was where the two halves met. Schofield’s was a genuine business — O’Banion really did arrange flowers, and did it beautifully — and it was also the front room of an enterprise built on stolen whiskey and nerve. He was, by every account, charming and funny and generous, quick with a joke and quicker with a gun, a devout man who carried a rosary and, it was widely believed, had personally killed more than one rival. The papers called him “Dion.” The people who knew him called him Dean. Neither name quite covered him.

Interior of Schofield’s flower shop in Chicago, with an X marking the location where Dean O’Banion was murdered in 1924.

Inside Schofield’s flower shop at 738 North State Street. The original 1930 publication marks the spot where Dean O’Banion was killed in November 1924. From Chicago Gang Wars in Pictures: X Marks the Spot (Spot Publishing Company, 1930). University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign / Internet Archive. Public domain.

What got him killed, most likely, was a double-cross. Some months earlier, O’Banion had gotten word that a brewery he secretly co-owned with Johnny Torrio — the man who, with his young lieutenant Al Capone, led O’Banion’s South Side rivals — was about to be raided by police. Instead of warning his partner, O’Banion sold Torrio his share of the doomed operation at a fine price, then let him walk straight into the raid. Torrio was arrested, humiliated, and out a small fortune. In the world these men lived in, that kind of insult was not the sort of thing a man survived. The three who came into the shop that morning were let in, and got close enough to take his hand, because O’Banion did not believe a handshake was anything to fear.

A king’s funeral and a closed door

O’Banion’s send-off, a few days later, was one of the most extravagant the city had ever witnessed. Tens of thousands of people lined the route. The casket was silver and bronze and had to be freighted in from the East. And the flowers — the flowers went beyond anything even a florist’s own shop could have dreamed, banked into walls and towers, sent by ordinary mourners and by men who had almost certainly ordered his death. Torrio sent flowers. Capone sent an enormous basket, signed, with a gambler’s flair, in one of his aliases. Exactly how many truckloads it took to carry Dean O’Banion to his grave is a question I’ve chased down a rabbit hole elsewhere; the honest answer is that we will never quite agree. The rivals who buried him in roses were making the same point the whole spectacle made: this was a world that honored its dead lavishly and killed them without a flicker of hesitation.

Crowd gathered outside Schofield’s flower shop on North State Street in Chicago shortly after Dean O’Banion’s murder in November 1924.

Crowd outside Schofield’s flower shop on North State Street shortly after the assassination of Dean O’Banion, November 1924. From Chicago Gang Wars in Pictures: X Marks the Spot (Spot Publishing Company, 1930). University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign / Internet Archive. Public domain.

For all the splendor, the one thing O’Banion could not have was a church. The archdiocese refused him a requiem Mass — a man of his reputation would not be blessed from the altar of Holy Name, whatever he had sung there as a boy. He was laid in unconsecrated ground at Mount Carmel Cemetery, outside the fence of the faithful. The altar boy got a king’s farewell from the underworld and a closed door from his God — an irony no novelist would dare to invent.

The shop keeps its dead

The flower shop was not finished with the dead. Two years later, almost to the season, the man who had stepped into O’Banion’s place on the North Side — Hymie Weiss — was cut down by machine-gun fire on the State Street sidewalk directly outside Schofield’s, so close that stray bullets chipped the cornerstone of Holy Name across the way, where the scars are said to linger still. Two leaders of the same North Side coalition, dead within two years, on the same block, in the shadow of the same cathedral. If anyone had truly held that ground, they would not have had to keep dying for it.

And behind each of these men stood a woman who had not been consulted about any of it. O’Banion left a widow — married to a florist she may or may not have fully understood, and now the most conspicuous grieving woman in Chicago for a season, standing at a graveside her Church would not bless. She had entered none of the rooms where the decisions that widowed her were made. That was the shape of this entire world for the women inside it: wives and widows and daughters left to navigate the fallout of choices they never got a vote on — the women whose survival, far more than any gangster’s funeral, is the real subject of my fiction about women remaking their lives in early twentieth-century America.

The flowers are long gone. The cathedral still stands, still scarred. And the shop on State Street, for one strange decade, was the place where Chicago’s underworld came to buy its roses — and, twice, left its dead on the sidewalk out front.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *